But I compared Swisscom with Wingo. I only mentioned Lebara because they are much cheaper and have exactly the same problem. During peak times, bandwidths are suddenly reduced to below 10 Mbps. And then suddenly you can no longer stream films. I can then switch back to the cheaper provider straight away.

Show original language (German)

I just think it’s a shame that Swisscom and Wingo don’t clearly communicate that mobile bandwidths fluctuate between 200 Mbps and 8 Mbps and are then prioritized during peak times depending on the subscription. And exactly when you need the bandwidth. Doesn’t that have anything to do with income or savings behavior?

Show original language (German)

@philipp_BREM0_1

What are you talking about 200Mbits-8Mbits? Theoretically, it can be almost nothing even with an expensive Swisscom Abo of 1000Mbits. Precisely because the speed in the mobile network always fluctuates enormously. That’s obvious, isn’t it? A mobile network is a shared medium.

Show original language (German)

With a 5G subscription of 30 francs per month, I don’t want to have bandwidth fluctuations between 200 and 8 Mbps and then notice that other Swisscom customers with prepaid cards have higher bandwidths at the same time.

Show original language (German)

I thought that 5G was invented so that you could stream a film properly on the Internet? But that’s exactly what doesn’t work during peak times. This is a deceptive package. You pay for 5G, but just when you need it, the bandwidth drops so low that the film starts to stutter.

Show original language (German)

The most expensive 5G-Wingo subscription is significantly cheaper. It is supposed to be cheaper because less support is provided and not because Swisscom prioritizes Wingo customers later in peak times.

Show original language (German)

Please give it a rest now. This discussion leads nowhere. I don’t feel like writing the reasons here again. Then cancel the Wingo subscription and take a blue Mobile subscription.

By the way, cell phone reception always plays a crucial role. Even if the speed Wingo decreases, a change of position within the house can work wonders, e.g. moving to another room on a different side, placing your cell phone by the window, etc.

Show original language (German)

Do you think it’s good that a subsidiary of Swisscom cannot clearly and clearly admit that the price difference is not only due to the difference in support, but also due to less bandwidth during peak times? I think it’s a shame when you don’t tell customers the truth.

Show original language (German)

I specifically bought the best Wingo 5G subscription, which is three times more expensive than the Lebara 5G subscription, because I thought I would get the same bandwidth as with my Swisscom prepaid 5G flat rate option. But unfortunately that is not the case during peak times.

Show original language (German)

There was no official statement about this from either Swisscom or Wingo, and there probably never will be. The assumption has been discussed several times here in the forum (most recently here) that Wingo traffic with lower priority than Swisscom traffic. That may be so, but as long as the prioritization only happens when the network is at full capacity, I don’t see any nefarious motives on the part of Swisscom or lies on the part of Wingo. According to the offer, the highest possible available bandwidth is offered, and somehow I can understand that with a limited offer, the cake is divided “fairly” (from the perspective of the more paying customers).

Personally, I don’t care about the cent per megabit ratio; I have a DSL Anschluss at home for streams. What is more important to me is the best possible coverage, even in very remote areas, and here Swisscom (and therefore also Wingo) is usually ahead of its competitors.

Show original language (German)

Have you tried turning it off and on again?


@philipp_BREM0_1 wrote:

And what is 5G for? That would then be unnecessary for you and you could save money with a 4G M-Budget subscription.


Exactly. I currently have a 4G device and a subscription that fits it perfectly.

I think 5G is a good thing for reasons of technical possibilities and tailored network coverage, but I’m currently missing the personal benefit.

Show original language (German)

Have you tried turning it off and on again?

But Swisscom and its subsidiaries charge a lot more money for 5G. An engine with more horsepower is sold to you at a higher price, but as soon as you press the tube during rush hour, the car drives slower than a moped. Isn’t that more than just “farm smart”?

Show original language (German)

@philipp_BREM0_1

This cannot be said in general terms either. This always depends on where you live or are currently staying and how well developed the network is there. With a well-developed network, I always have very high speeds with 5G, even at peak times. Yes, even in Zurich last summer I always had well over 100Mbits at the ZüriFäscht with 100,000 visitors. Of course, the network capacity is additionally increased on such major events, but still. Yes, many factors have an influence here.

Show original language (German)

It’s exciting that Swisscom can strengthen the network at Zürifäscht, but in the holiday resorts it has to “get” the bandwidth from Wingo customers at Christmas/New Year. I believe that Swisscom has two goals:

1. She doesn’t want to cannibalize fixed-line customers too much with the 5G network.
2. She doesn’t want to “lose” too many 5G customers to Wingo.

Of course, I understand Swisscom’s corporate goals. But do you have to lie to Wingo customers? I think that’s not appropriate.

Show original language (German)

I asked Wingo and Swisscom whether the bandwidth of my 5G Wingo subscription is reduced more during peak times (from 100 to less than 10 Mbps) than for 5G Swisscom customers. Both companies have said that such prioritization will not be done for 5G subscriptions.

However, I was able to measure clear differences on my own iPhone with a dual SIM card from both providers at the same time: Swisscom prepaid data flat option had 5x higher bandwidth than the 5G Wingo subscription.

Show original language (German)